Image: MV Bangus, one of the two vessels involved in the pilot project
Klaveness Combination Carriers (KCC) and Louis Dreyfus Company (LDC) are challenging traditional time charter contracting by testing commercial terms that give both owner and charterer an incentive to improve voyage efficiency.
The approach delivered promising results. Two pilot voyages consumed more than 100 tons (well over 10%) less fuel per voyage compared to similar historical trips, when corrected for speed, draft, weather and total sailing distance. This represents approximately USD 100,000 per voyage at today’s bunker prices, with the fuel reduction also reducing the environmental footprint of the voyage.
The results came from combining new contractual incentives with targeted energy-efficiency measures.
What is the Performance Adjusted Charter Management (PACMAN) framework
While smarter vessel designs, new technologies, and better onshore logistics have continued to evolve, the commercial terms governing time charter trips have remained largely unchanged. This can limit the incentives for owners and charterers to invest in, and pursue, further efficiency improvements.
Challenging this misalignment, KCC developed the Performance Adjusted Charter Management framework (PACMAN).
Under traditional time charter terms, vessels are measured against a fixed speed/consumption figure provided by the owner, with strict weather exclusion parameters. While this protects owners from consumption claims caused by adverse weather, these exclusions limit owners and charterers from working together to optimize the voyage.
This was evident on KCC’s two pilot voyages, where normal weather exclusions would typically have excluded 80% of the time at sea from the performance assessment. This would have left the charterer with limited performance guarantees under real life conditions and the ship owner with less incentive to invest in efficiency improvements.
PACMAN takes a different approach. Rather than assessing day-to-day adherence to the vessel description, it assesses the vessel performance across the full voyage, using weather-adjusted calculations and independent third-party verification. By expanding the weather conditions considered acceptable for the performance assessment, PACMAN gives the charterer stronger guarantees for the vessel’s actual performance.
The framework also gives the charterer greater flexibility in operating speeds and arrival times. For example, savings in voyage duration can be balanced against any corresponding overconsumption.
When the vessel performs above its agreed performance benchmark, the value created through fuel and/or time savings is shared between the owner and charterer. If the vessel underperforms, the charterer is fully compensated. This creates a strong incentive for both parties to optimize the voyage and for the owner to make further investments in energy efficiency.
Constant speed
Crew energy focus
Figure: Traditional TC terms vs with PACMAN
Putting PACMAN to the test
KCC tested the framework with LDC on two outbound time charter trips involving the CLEANBU vessels, MV Barracuda and MV Bangus. Together, the two voyages provided an opportunity to test the framework in different operating conditions.
With PACMAN in place, KCC carried out hull and propeller inspections and cleaning, introduced advanced dynamic weather routing, and placed additional focus on fuel optimization on board.
Both voyages recorded fuel consumption more than 100 metric tons less per voyage compared to similar voyages performed by sister vessels, after correcting for speed, draft, weather and total sailing distance. Third party verification on the vessel’s performance was carried out by Toqua and StormGeo.
The results demonstrate a clear win-win. Savings of approximately USD 100,000 per voyage compared with historical voyages were shared between KCC and LDC, while also reducing the emissions footprint. Importantly, the savings were achieved with limited vessel investments that will also contribute to improved performance on future employment.
Trading efficiency in practice
The pilots demonstrate that efficiency is not only a technical question. Commercial terms can determine whether owners and charterers have the freedom and incentive to invest, share data, and optimize the voyage as a whole.
KCC has the ambition to incorporate this into an increasing number of its future voyages under time charter terms.